Michael,
I live right down on the south coast, so snow is too rare to answer honestly.
In high winds and rain though, the car will be twitchier and require greater concentration and involvement than a 'point and go' car - but that's why you are considering one. It will be as forgiving as you are!
Some years ago i had a 944 which i traded because it was just too dull and perfect. That went for a tvr 350i, but the 911 is way way way way way better than either. They are actually surprisingly practical and civilised cars on dark mucky nights, the build quality is obviously excellent, but they are tremendous fun as well.
The oddities are well Documented - floor hinged pedals (in the middle of the car on RHD) strange control positions, inability to see the major instruments and hang on to the wheel at the same time ... but this is a car that only had relatively small evolutionary changes over 35-odd years, so it must be quite good!
I paid P&P the lower price as the car had only recently had a 12k. It was inspected by Jaz and MOTed. Jaz picked up some faults, but that seemed fair given the price. Do keep a few bob back though: I decided to live with the faults for a few months to ensure it was the right car for me. I recently bit the bullet and gave it JZ Machtech for a 12k. At that point it seems daft not to change brake fluid, gearbox fluid, fix the heater in preparation for the winter... and if you need a new exhaust, why not have a stainless one? Oh, and you don't want discs and pads that are near the end do you?
Have a look at 911 & porsche this month
http://www.chpltd.com
for the free supplement and 944 comparison, by the way.
I would have no hesitation in using P&P again when the time comes, although as Jamie points out, people speak equally well of Adrian Crawford and others, so if the car looks right and the dealer's well respected I'd be happy.
Oh yeah, lose the other car - you won't use it!
Migration info. Legacy thread was 6519