Porsche 911 UK Enthusiasts Online Community Discussion Forum GB

Welcome to the @Porsche911UK website. Register a free account today to become a member! Sign up is quick and easy, then you can view, participate in topics and posts across the site that covers all things Porsche.

Already registered and looking to recovery your account, select 'login in' and then the 'forget your password' option.

First Impression drivnng the 911C2s 991 PDK

theogeor

Albert Park
Joined
22 Sep 2008
Messages
1,504
Today I went with one of my neighbors at OPC Reading to see the new 991 Porsche first hand. His brother in the US is waiting for a delivery of his 991 so both of us were curious and eager to go and see the cars and compare them and see if it will tick the boxes so as to start thinking of a change over

Despite the weather been terrible we still went ahead :)

At OPC Reading they have a number of them on the showroom all of then 911C2S with no 911C2 to be seen anywhere. We had a good look both inside and outside and that was helped by the fact that a GTS 997 with the same color combination was next to one of them so comparisons were easier

Externally the car as we know its bigger than the 997 and you can immediately tell . Also the edge of the doors or where the window starts look higher. And of course the back looks different. The overall shape gave me the impression of moving slightly away from the classic shape in a sense what the 996 did 15 years or so ago. The front lights are interesting. Although the glass from far looks similar to the 997 when you look at it is more curvy and I believe that is to do with aerodynamics.
Overall I would stay the car looks fantastic but still need to digest its looks compared with the 997 that has more classic look (Hope I am not biased here :D )

Internally the car look much more modern and I can see items that came from the Panamera as well some of the things we saw in the Gen2 cars. The one obvious thing that is missing is the parking brake which is now electromechanical and looks like identical to the ones on the Mercs and VWs (reminded me the one I saw on my brothers VW Passat) The centre console is much higher than the 997 as with no Hand Brake there is more flexibility to play with the space. Also that area is full of buttons for all the functions and extras you want on the car.

Saying that I could not fault that approach but call me old fashion I love to see a hand brake :oops: And last but not least is more spaciour at the back than the 997. I would say it has 1-1.5" more leg room for the rear passengers/kids at the same driving position like the 997

After our self tour and a nice cappuccino we spoke with one of the Sales Guys and started having a more General discussion around what is popular and what is not. It was interesting to hear that most if not all the cars so far have been with the PDK. He said that he personally has not sold a manual yet and he was not sure what the other colleagues have done . Also it was interesting to hear that so far the balance between 911C2 and 911C2s in terms of sales is more even than in the 997 but is too early to tell

And then of course came the test drive. Craig took us initially out on a 911C2s PDK with a number of extras (Electric seats, Sunroof, cruse control etc) including Sport and SportPlus which is the one that was the most interesting from my point of view. He demonstrated both the performance and the handling of the car and that was impressive as all the roads were extremely wet and greasy.

I was really impressed how the car was handling in those conditions and so big improvement compare with the 997. Also it was obvious that without the Sport or SportPlus on the gear change was just about ok or even a bit lazy but with Sports on all 400 horses are awake and kicking. The right also felt smother compare with my 997 with the PASM but that might be related to the tyre pressure on the tyres which in my opinion was low i.e 29 front and 38 rear (I run 34 front and 40 rear)

After few minutes it was my tern to drive it. My initial thoughts were confirmed around the handling and the performance with the Sports mode on. Also its worth noting despite me been a manual car person I was very happy with the PDK and it was doing all the work better than I could do in the manual. Also its worth mentioning that the PDK is much better than the earlier ones that I drove either on a boxter S or 997 Gen2. It looks like the got the software algorithm right this time :)

Now everything was fantastic and the car as I said looked much more well balanced than the 997 and that can explain the much better quoted lap times at the Ring. But there is one thing I was not comfortable with and that was the steering wheel. Yes its very responsive but does not give you any feedback of the road conditions. Even uneven B roads felt like a Motorway with smooth surface. I could not feel any difference when the road surface conditions were changing. Now would that thing put me off ? Not sure yet... I need to think about it

After the test drive finished I jumped into my car and through the B roads I headed back home . The steering wheel differences were confirmed as well as all the other positive things. By no means the handling on the 997 was bad but the 991 is in a different class. As for the cabin yes my Gen1 does not look as good as either the Gen2 or the 991 but... Now performance with the PDK... Well that I would say is the reason that might make me start planning for a change .... but..... Still not convinced ... as I need to digest the following

1. Car overall look (something that very likely I would end up liking )
2. Steering wheel feedback when driving (one of the pleasures having a sports car)


Those are might thoughts for the time


Regards

Theo
 
Cheers Theo :thumb: Just wondering if you'd dared to enquire about a px! I was looking at moving to a 997 Turbo Gen I or a late 997 Carrera 4S/GTS maybe sometime later this year but the more I read/see/hear of the 991, I might wait until prices are more reasonable and jump to that instead. It's going to be a long wait, longer still if I hold out for a 991 C4.

~ Maxie
 
Maxie said:
Cheers Theo :thumb: Just wondering if you'd dared to enquire about a px! I was looking at moving to a 997 Turbo Gen I or a late 997 Carrera 4S/GTS maybe sometime later this year but the more I read/see/hear of the 991, I might wait until prices are more reasonable and jump to that instead. It's going to be a long wait, longer still if I hold out for a 991 C4.

~ Maxie

I did not want to go into discussion about PX but based on his comments I would be looking now mid 20s or a bit more but I would say max 27K which is not bad ; Remember they want to sell ...
The C4S (and assume GTS etc ) will become available in the next Frankfurt Motorshow so still long way to go . The 991 Turbo is more likely to be a 2013 release.
And something else about the Steering Wheel. I was driving tonight my wifes Mercedes A Class (2011 model) with electo-mechanical steering wheel and the feeling was identical to the 991. That made me even more confused .... and started having deeper thoughts about it . Very likely that is what we will see in the near future in most cars

Theo
 
theogeor said:
And something else about the Steering Wheel. I was driving tonight my wifes Mercedes A Class (2011 model) with electo-mechanical steering wheel and the feeling was identical to the 991. That made me even more confused .... and started having deeper thoughts about it . Very likely that is what we will see in the near future in most cars

Theo

really ?

that is interesting, I wonder where the system came from
 
911UK said:
theogeor said:
And something else about the Steering Wheel. I was driving tonight my wifes Mercedes A Class (2011 model) with electo-mechanical steering wheel and the feeling was identical to the 991. That made me even more confused .... and started having deeper thoughts about it . Very likely that is what we will see in the near future in most cars

Theo

really ?

that is interesting, I wonder where the system came from

Not sure about that but interesting enough VW have their own electro-mechanical steering... but I would say is more likely someone else behind like bosh so both Mercedes & VW and Porsche might have the same roots.

As I said after a bit of research it looks like most cars are moving towards that direction. For the majority that should be fine but for sports cars not sure..

Theo
 
My BIG concern is that it's all well and good that the car looks awesome (tick) the car sounds awesome (tick) handles great (tick) BUT doesnt feel good

I havn't tried one yet so it may not be as bad as say an Audi but I wouldn't bother if this vital aspect was missing as badly as some are describing

I would be shocked though if Porsche have messed this up. I have faith, they do most things + improvements so well

Just my thoughts :thumb:
 
theogeor said:
Not sure about that but interesting enough VW have their own electro-mechanical steering... but I would say is more likely someone else behind like bosh so both Mercedes & VW and Porsche might have the same roots.

As I said after a bit of research it looks like most cars are moving towards that direction. For the majority that should be fine but for sports cars not sure..

Theo

Porsche. Mercedes, VW and other OEM's use ZF Lenksysteme GmbH's electric power steering system called ZF Servolectric. So it is very much the same design architecture.
 
OP, did the car have PDCC which is in a different league again road holding wise, limo smooth in a straight line miles better ride than a 997 on 19" :thumb:

Mine get's better and better the longer I drive it :drive:
 
Rimmer said:
Mine get's better and better the longer I drive it :drive:

:thumb: and 8) and :worship:
 
Twilight said:
theogeor said:
Not sure about that but interesting enough VW have their own electro-mechanical steering... but I would say is more likely someone else behind like bosh so both Mercedes & VW and Porsche might have the same roots.

As I said after a bit of research it looks like most cars are moving towards that direction. For the majority that should be fine but for sports cars not sure..

Theo

Porsche. Mercedes, VW and other OEM's use ZF Lenksysteme GmbH's electric power steering system called ZF Servolectric. So it is very much the same design architecture.

ZF (Zepplin Friedrichshafen) weren't very good at airships and, although the company's produced hundreds of thousands of automatic gearboxes, it was a ZF that bust in my Jaguar.

ZF steering now? :?
 
I was also at Reading OPC this Monday looking as I was working that way. Having driven the 991s for a prolonged period I agree with Theo, but I found the steering feel ok. It was a very dry day and we were going for it at times. I thought the feel of the wheel did let me know what was going on, but I am not a track day driver. Would not put me off one.

What did, was the Carrera 4 GTS they have, the rear end on that embarrasses the 991, I could not stop looking at it with the piped lettering in black contrasting the grey paint. That car must be the complete 997 and I so wanted it. Whereas the 991 is just nice.
 
Tinker said:
ZF (Zepplin Friedrichshafen) weren't very good at airships and, although the company's produced hundreds of thousands of automatic gearboxes, it was a ZF that bust in my Jaguar.

ZF steering now? :?

Ignorance is bliss.

What I mean by that sentence is that ZF should be considered one of the top players in this field of engineering. No matter what bust in you Jaguar, as you can probably figure out, it could have caused by almost anything.

What comes into the electric power steering, we still are at quite early stages of development. Maybe they can provide us with a better feel in the future. Honda NSX used electromechanical power steering in 90's, but too bad Honda systems still lack in feel at the 10's.
 
Actually, ZF were world class in airships.

The plight of the early models was defined by the, then, lack of helium.
 

New Threads

Forum statistics

Threads
124,531
Messages
1,441,212
Members
48,940
Latest member
yewcorner
Back
Top